The Scottsboro Boys

Star rating: ***

Garrick Theatre

London WC2

Friday 21st November 2014

“During the 1930s, much of the world’s attention was riveted on the “Scottsboro Boys,” nine black youths falsely charged with raping two white women in Alabama. This case, more than any other event in the South during the 1930s, revealed the barbarous treatment of blacks. The case began on March 25, 1931, when a number of white and black youths were riding on a freight train, travelling to see if they could find work. A fight broke out between a group of black and white hobos, and the whites were thrown off the train. They reported the incident to a stationmaster, who wired ahead for officials to stop the train at a town called Paint Rock. Dozens of armed men rounded up nine black youths and took them to jail. They were about to be charged with assault when two white women, dressed in boys clothing, were discovered hiding on the train. Although there was no evidence connecting the youth to the women, the nine youths were charged with raping the women. The women — who had had sexual relations with some of the white men thrown off the train and fearing prosecution for their sexual activity with the white men — agreed to testify against the black youths. The trial was held in the town of Scottsboro, Alabama. The all-white jury convicted the nine, and all but the youngest, who was 12 years old, were sentenced to death.

The announcement of the verdict and sentences brought a roar of protest in the North. The Communist Party USA took charge of the case and carried out a two-fold battle — in the courts and on the streets. In 1932 the U.S. Supreme Court overturned the convictions (Powell v. Alabama) on the grounds that the defendants had not received adequate legal counsel in a capital case. The state of Alabama then retried one of the accused, Haywood Patterson, and once again convicted him. But the trial judge, James Horton, set aside the verdict on the grounds that he did not believe the defendant committed the crime. That decision caused him to be defeated in the next election. The state then retried Clarence Norris to see if the Supreme Court would again intervene. Norris was sentenced to death, but in 1935 decision the U.S. Supreme Court (Norris v. Alabama) overturned this conviction, ruling that the state had excluded blacks from juries. Alabama again tried and convicted Haywood Patterson, this time sentencing him to 75 years in prison. Further trials of the rest of the defendants resulted in more reconvictions and appeals until, after persistent pressure both Northern and Southern groups, Alabama freed the four youngest defendants (who had already served six years in jail) and later paroled all but Patterson. Patterson escaped in 1948 and fled to Michigan, where, three years later, he was convicted of manslaughter and died in prison. The last known surviving member of the group, Clarence Norris, fled to the North after his parole in 1946 and was granted a full pardon by the Governor of Alabama in 1976.”


Tiemo Talk of the Town review

The serious story of The Scottsboro Boys was told via high energy musical format, with plenty of foot tapping song and dance. The above précis of the real life story tells you all you need to know about the historical background to this true life story. The skill of the musical is in bringing the clear injustice the 9 young men suffered vividly and memorably to life. The cast did so expertly. It came across loud and clear that the 9 men should never have been found guilty at all. It was as clear as daylight that they were innocent and had not had any sexual relations with the two women whatsoever.

I have to say amusing as the show was, in spite of the subject matter, I found the wide-eyed innocence and dancing tended too much towards tomfoolery for my liking. It seemed old hat and not really what I want to see on the West End stage in this day and age, especially for a serious drama about racial injustice.

It would have served the story better to have conveyed events in a more sober, more serious way, with a seriously run trial on stage. Instead they made it out to be a joke. I can see why they used this conceit to cleverly convey the message that the trials were in fact an absolute joke with no respect for legalities. They were just there to secure convictions against the Black guys irrespective of whether any facts supported a guilty verdict.

Though it’s a very old story dating back to 1931, it sadly resonates today all too clearly in the USA, her in the UK and worldwide as innocent Black men are being killed by US policemen or dying in police custody in English jails for nothing more than being Black.

The Scottsboro Boys runs at the Garrick Theatre, London, until 21st February 2015.

Review © Tiemo Talk of the Town

Photograph © Johan Persson

Thank you for reading our review. We hope you enjoyed it and that if you did, will share it with others who have the same interest in this topic and may also appreciate the chance to read it.


The Scottsboro Boys official trailer


1. Information and tickets for The Scottsboro Boys

2. History of the Scottsboro Boys – PBS




This entry was posted in Theatre reviews and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

1 Response to The Scottsboro Boys

  1. Pingback: Strangers Welcome: review | tiemotalkofthetown

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s